By WorldwideScope World Desk
U.S. Special Envoy Steve Witkoff has drawn sharp international scrutiny and immediate political backlash after publicly lauding Russian President Vladimir Putin as a “humanitarian” during a high-stakes diplomatic meeting in St. Petersburg. The comments came as Moscow agreed to release Stephen Hubbard, a 74-year-old American citizen who had been imprisoned in Russia for more than four years.
Video of the encounter showed Witkoff offering personal thanks to Putin, telling the Russian leader, “Because of you, he’s going home to his family.”
However, foreign policy analysts and legal experts note that the public gesture offers significant diplomatic leverage and goodwill to the Kremlin—all while costing Putin, who remains wanted for war crimes by the International Criminal Court (ICC), virtually nothing in return.
The Release of Stephen Hubbard
Stephen Hubbard, a Michigan native, was detained by Russian forces in Ukraine in 2022 and subsequently sentenced to over six years in prison on charges of acting as a mercenary—allegations that the U.S. State Department and Hubbard’s family consistently rejected as fabricated.
His release followed face-to-face negotiations in St. Petersburg between Witkoff and Putin. According to administration officials, no high-profile Russian prisoners were exchanged as part of the release.
“Russia asked for no one in return — No exchange took place.”
— Remarks regarding recent American detainee releases on humanitarian grounds.
Why the ‘Humanitarian’ Label Sparks Backlash
Witkoff’s decision to praise Putin as a “humanitarian” sparked immediate condemnation from human rights advocates, foreign policy veterans, and lawmakers across Washington.
Critics highlighted several key contradictions:
- War Crimes Indictment: Putin remains under an active arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court (ICC) for alleged war crimes involving the unlawful deportation of Ukrainian children.
- Hostage Diplomacy: Analysts point out that detaining foreign citizens on dubious charges to later use them as political bargaining chips is a well-established tactic of “hostage diplomacy” rather than an act of benevolence.
- Low Cost, High Returns: Releasing an elderly, wrongfully detained American costs the Kremlin virtually no geopolitical capital, yet earns immediate praise and legitimizes diplomatic channels with the U.S. administration.
Strategic Shift in U.S.–Russia Relations
Hubbard’s release comes amid a broader, highly controversial recalibration of U.S. policy toward Moscow:
- Sanctions & Trade: The Trump administration recently waived select sanctions against Russian energy entities, alongside announcing agreements regarding Russian fuel exports to global markets.
- U.S. Envoy Diplomacy: Witkoff’s St. Petersburg mission represents a continuing effort by Washington to secure the freedom of remaining wrongfully detained Americans while keeping open direct bilateral channels with Putin.
While Hubbard’s family expressed profound relief over his impending return, the optics of labeling a Kremlin leader facing war crimes allegations a “humanitarian” ensure that the diplomatic win will remain heavily debated.
Also read: Is BRICS More Powerful Than G7 in 2026? The Real Answer